Personally I would
not think of this essay as a college essay, more along the lines of a story
telling out of a book. which is what it is. But analyzing it against the book
the Nuts and Bolts Of College Writing by Harvey, Sedaris seems to
be a pretty good writer.
The book starts out
talking about how all of these college kids think that they need to sound smart
so they adopt this very pompous style of writing. I would not call his writing
style Pompous in fact I might call it a little humble because he talks about
how he is forty-one and returning to college (David Sedaris) Later in the book
he talks about how he "took to spending four hours a night on my home
work" because he wanted to create an identity for himself. He wanted the
teacher to notice him, but in a good way. Harvey also talks about how people
who need to be good writers use big words to make themselves seem smarter while
good writers know the importance of the smaller words. I would categorize
Sedaris as the writer who knows the importance of the small words, because he
never uses gigantic words to pump up his vocabulary.
Another section
Sedaris follows very well is chapter three: Flow. Harvey talks about keeping
the same subject and not straying because its extremely confusing to keep up
with. Sedaris keeps the same subject the whole time, French class. He never
strays from the topic whether to talk about his French teacher or his French
homework or speaking French. Another part of the flow section was keeping
consistent characters which Sedaris does very well. Instead of introducing us
to a bunch of the kids from the class he stays consistent with just the Teacher
of the French class. Harvey also talks about "the logical turns and links"
which he uses quite frequently. One of the most frequently used is the cause
links like when he says "The first day of class was nerve-racking because
I knew I'd be expected to perform" (David Sedaris). This is an example of
a cause link because of the word because, it shows the reason or cause for the
action.
My favorite thing
that Harvey mentions in his book is Gracefulness. he talks about a specific
idea called rhetoric, which in the writing world is more specific to mean the
"the science or art of persuasion by means of stylistic or structural
techniques" (Michael Harvey). Sedaris uses this very well when it comes to
his teacher. He tells us constantly about how his teacher is harsh, unpleasant,
and very hard to please. one great example of how he uses words to make his
teacher unlikeable is this quote " She crouched low for her attack, placed her hands on
the young woman’s desk, and leaned close, saying, 'Oh yeah? And do you love
your little war?'" (David Sedaris) with this quote he characterizes her in a way that makes he seem extremely scary and unlikeable.
Overall i think that
Sedaris did a very good job with his essay. It flowed very well there did not
seem to be any grammatical errors he did not use the pompous style that so many
writers do and gracefulness.
~Emily Mackson
Emily,
ReplyDeletethe first thing that struck me on your essay was that the first part talks about how you DON'T think it a college essay, but then your thesis is that he is a very good writer, which is a bit incongruous. Later on in the essay your theme is clear, but that first paragraph seems a bit rocky. Also, the citations could use some work, and I am not really sure what you are getting at in your last paragraph.
Other than that really, I think this was a fantastic essay. Your topic sentences were clear and defined and you had really well organized supports, too!
Good Job
Erin Donahue
Very clear, very strong, very organized essay. The only thing I would change is some of the paragraphs get very repetitive "Harvey said this.... then Sedaris said that". I mean, that's sort of the outline for this essay, but you are definitely capable of presenting these ideas in a more engaging way. And, like Erin said, now we know how to cite, so you'll be fine.
ReplyDeleteGood work.
Emily,
ReplyDeleteI think that you have written a very well organized and structured essay here. I think that you really got your point across and made your thoughts clear with your examples. You did a nice job of relating the two! Good work!